June 26, 2016

Partly sunny

Former Brunswick Hills woman, a suspect in husbands’ deaths, dies

From staff and wire reports

CHARLOTTE, N.C. — To the outside world, Betty Neumar was a diminutive Georgia grandmother with a shock of white hair who operated beauty shops, attended church and raised money for charity. No one asked questions when her last husband died.

It wasn’t until North Carolina investigators in 2008 reopened a 25-year-old murder case that the dark secrets of her past began to unravel. Police discovered that Neumar had left behind a decades-long trail of five dead husbands in five states.

Betty Neumar

Betty Neumar

On Nov. 27, 1970, Neumar’s first husband, Clarence Malone, was shot in the back of the head outside his Brunswick Hills Township business, Collision Body Shop, 2333 Pearl Road. The Medina County coroner at the time, Andrew J. Karson, ruled the death a homicide.

In 2008, Ken Baca, then-chief deputy of the Medina County Sheriff’s Office, said the Stanly County (N.C.) Sheriff’s Office contacted his department after Neumar was arrested.

Sheriff’s investigators could find no motive for the shooting of Malone after interviewing about 20 witnesses, a Gazette story from Dec. 5, 1970, said. It also said investigators found Malone had “too many enemies to make the investigation easy.”

Baca said detectives in 2008 were looking over original witness statements, but were discovering many of them had died.

Any hope of answering lingering questions of her husbands’ deaths — or the missing pieces of her life — faded Monday upon word the 79-year-old Neumar died of an illness in a Louisiana hospital.

“She took all those secrets to the grave,” said Al Gentry, who spent 25 years pressing North Carolina authorities in vain to re-examine the death of his brother, Harold Gentry, Neumar’s fourth husband.

Neumar died late Sunday or early Monday, her son-in-law Terry Sanders told The Associated Press.

“She was a tough country girl and fought through a lot of pain,” said Sanders, who has been married 38 years to Neumar’s daughter, Peggy.

North Carolina authorities said they planned to look into her death. She was free on $300,000 bond on three counts of solicitation to commit first-degree murder in the 1986 death of Harold Gentry. Her trial was postponed numerous times since her arrest in 2008.

“We’re going to make sure we examine the death certificate,” Stanly County Sheriff Rick Burris said.

While investigating Gentry’s death, authorities discovered Neumar had been married five times since the 1950s and each union ended in her husband’s death. Investigators in three states reopened several of the cases but have since closed them.

For Al Gentry, Neumar’s death is bittersweet. He spent a good part of his adult life pushing law enforcement authorities to solve the case — and he says he knows who was responsible: Neumar. The case was finally reopened in January 2008 after he asked Burris, then the newly elected sheriff, to look into it.

“I’m numb,” said Gentry, 65, of Rockwell, N.C. “I wanted justice, and we’re not going to get it.”

He said there were too many delays: the first was in the initial police investigation in 1986 and later with prosecutors. Her trial was supposed to have started in February, but was postponed to give a newly elected prosecutor more time to prepare.

“We still haven’t answered the question: Who actually killed my brother?” he said.

The mysteries in Neumar’s past may never be solved.

From the beginning, law enforcement authorities told The Associated Press they had struggled to piece together details of Neumar’s life because her story kept changing. But interviews, documents and court records provided an outline of her history in North Carolina, Ohio, Florida and Georgia, the states where she was married.

She was born Betty Johnson in 1931 in Ironton, a hardscrabble southeastern Ohio town along the West Virginia border. Her father was a coal miner. She graduated from high school in 1949 and married Malone in November 1950. She told her friends she wanted to leave her hometown for a better life. It’s unclear when their marriage broke up. Their son, Gary, was born March 13, 1952.

After Malone’s death, Gary was adopted by Neumar’s second husband, James A. Flynn, although it’s unclear when she met or married him. She told investigators he “died on a pier” somewhere in New York in the mid-1950s. She and Flynn had a daughter, Peggy.

In the mid-1960s, Neumar, who was a beautician in Jacksonville, Fla., married husband No. 3: Richard Sills, who was in the Navy. For the last two years, Sills’ son, Michael, has been urging police to reinvestigate his father’s death, which was ruled a suicide.

On April 18, 1967, police found his body in the bedroom of the couple’s mobile home in Big Coppitt Key, Fla. Neumar told police they were alone and arguing, when he pulled out a gun and shot himself.

Sills said he knew nothing about how his father died until he was contacted in 2009 by The Associated Press about Neumar’s past. Since then, he has been delving into the records.

After Neumar was charged in North Carolina, the Monroe County Sheriff’s Department in Florida took another look at the death.

They uncovered Navy medical examiner documents revealing Richard Sills may have been shot twice — not once, as Neumar told police. One bullet from the .22-caliber pistol pierced his heart, while a second may have sliced his liver.

The Navy medical examiner at the time said without an autopsy, he would be unable to determine whether Richard Sills was shot once or twice. No autopsy was performed when he died. And without knowing the number of gunshot wounds, there’s no way to know if his death was a suicide or homicide.

County investigators planned in 2009 to exhume Sills’ body from an Ocala, Fla., cemetery for an autopsy, but determined a statute of limitations applied to the case. Investigators have said Florida law sets a time limit on prosecution of some categories of homicide, including involuntary manslaughter, but not on premeditated — or first-degree — murder.

Michael Sills then turned to the Naval Criminal Investigative Service cold case squad. The unit is studying the evidence and could decide to investigate. But that could end with Neumar’s death.

After Richard Sills’ death, she met Harold Gentry, who was in the Army, and they married Jan. 19, 1968. The couple moved to Norwood, N.C., about an hour east of Charlotte, in the late 1970s after he retired from the Army after 21 years of service.

Over the years, Al Gentry recalls, she told the family she had been a nurse and her first husband died of cancer. Her stories always changed. At first pleasant, she grew to become “cold” to his brother and family, Al Gentry said. Other family members also said she could be verbally abusive — her mood changing quickly — especially after she had a few drinks.

In November 1985, her son, Gary, was found shot to death in his Ohio apartment. Police ruled his death a suicide. But Neumar was the beneficiary on her son’s life insurance policy — even though he was married with children. She also collected about $20,000 in insurance money when Harold Gentry was killed.

She also had a life insurance policy on husband No. 5, John Neumar, who died in October 2007. She met him when she moved to Augusta, Ga., after Harold Gentry’s death. There, she opened a beauty shop and did charity work. People in the community called her Bea and knew nothing about her past.

Georgia authorities two years ago closed their re-examination of the death of John Neumar, saying they had no evidence she was involved. His family has criticized the conclusion.

At the time, John Neumar’s family said she isolated him from them, and they didn’t know he had died until reading his obituary in the local newspaper. When they visited the funeral home, they discovered he had been cremated.

Gazette staff About Gazette staff

The Gazette is Medina County's daily local news source, serving the community since 1832. Contact The Gazette's news department at (330) 721-4065 or areanews@medina-gazette.com.